Skip to content

Conversation

@decebals
Copy link
Owner

@decebals decebals commented Feb 3, 2026

Testing the new skill validation workflow. Close without merge after verification.

@decebals decebals force-pushed the test/skill-review-workflow branch 4 times, most recently from 1374df8 to a7091ec Compare February 3, 2026 22:22
@decebals decebals force-pushed the test/skill-review-workflow branch from a7091ec to 242547e Compare February 4, 2026 12:02
@github-actions
Copy link

github-actions bot commented Feb 4, 2026

Skill Review: clean-code Enhancement

Verdict: ✅ APPROVE


Changed Files

  • .claude/skills/clean-code/SKILL.md - Added one trigger phrase to the "When to Use" section

Analysis

Structure ✅

  • SKILL.md has required frontmatter with name and description
  • README.md exists with human documentation
  • Follows folder convention: .claude/skills/clean-code/

Overlap Check ✅

No significant overlap. The change is a minor enhancement to an existing, focused micro-level skill:

  • clean-code (Micro): Function/variable/naming level - DRY/KISS/YAGNI principles
  • solid-principles (Micro/Meso): Class design - S.O.L.I.D principles
  • java-code-review (Meso): Comprehensive code review checklist
  • design-patterns (Meso): Class collaboration patterns

These skills operate at different levels and serve different purposes. This change reinforces the clean-code skill's existing scope.

Quality ✅

  • Substantive: The new trigger phrase "Simplifying convoluted logic" directly aligns with existing content in the skill (Guard Clauses section, refactoring techniques)
  • Actionable: All existing checklists and examples remain substantive and Java-specific
  • Scope: Checklist items remain well under 15 items
  • Alignment: The trigger phrase naturally fits the "When to Use" section alongside related triggers like "Reducing complexity" and "Improving naming"

Content Assessment ✅

The SKILL.md file already covers:

  • ✅ Concrete, actionable Java examples
  • ✅ Anti-patterns (BAD) vs patterns (GOOD)
  • ✅ Refactoring techniques with clear instructions
  • ✅ Deep coverage of convoluted logic (Guard Clauses section, nested conditional refactoring, etc.)

Summary

This is a straightforward enhancement to an existing skill. The new trigger phrase "Simplifying convoluted logic" is well-supported by the existing content (Guard Clauses section, nested conditional refactoring, etc.). It improves discoverability without adding any new functionality or creating overlap with other skills.

Ready to merge. 🚀

- Concise, professional format
- No emojis
- Clear pass/fail structure
- Focus on actionable feedback
@decebals
Copy link
Owner Author

decebals commented Feb 4, 2026

Test completed successfully. Skill review workflow is working.

@decebals decebals closed this Feb 4, 2026
@decebals decebals deleted the test/skill-review-workflow branch February 4, 2026 12:30
@github-actions
Copy link

github-actions bot commented Feb 4, 2026

Verdict: APPROVE

Files reviewed:

  • .claude/skills/clean-code/SKILL.md

Findings:

  • Structure: ✅ Pass - SKILL.md has proper frontmatter, README.md exists
  • Overlap: ✅ Pass - Addition complements DRY/KISS/YAGNI, no conflict with related skills
  • Quality: ✅ Pass - Skill is substantive with comprehensive Java examples, actionable checklist (8 items), all examples Java-specific

Action required: None - ready to merge

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant